4 Mar
In the midst of what is quickly becoming Puppygate 2008, it is interesting (to me at least) to note that, many of the same internet-dwellers that believe 9/11 was an engineered event meant to shift the will of the general population in favor of a certain socio-political viewpoint, are so quick to vouch for the authenticity of a grainy, unsourced YouTube clip. I’m not saying its NOT real, however, I’m definitely not gonna say it is. As the above video points out, remember not so long ago the whole “bird shitting in the reporters mouth” clip that was a supposed outtake of real news footage? Well it turned out to be fake, after of course, getting a few million views on YouTube and getting linked by Huffington Post along with every other blog, most of whom are probably posting this puppy video as we speak. Like I said, maybe this video is real. Maybe I’m totally off base. But I’d rather be the guy who was wrong about it being some engineered viral meme, than the guy that’s wrong but can’t go back and unpost a United State’s Marine’s mother’s home address, or worse yet, threats of physical violence.
And even if it is real, Who are we to decry the senseless death of one animal, when everyday in every single city in our entire country, who legions of animals are routinely slaughtered, for food, because they’re “pests”, or because they happen to walk onto our roads? Or how about the 3-4 million dogs and cats euthanized each year at United States animal shelters. Where’s the outcry over that? How many hundreds of thousands of puppies do you think that includes? Why is no one storming the gates of these humane societies and demanding justice?
If we want to punish someone for purposely mistreating animals why don’t we start with the people we can at least prove are doing it? Such as the factory farms that produce the majority of America’s meat? Pigs, which are known to be as intelligent, if not more so than dogs are just one of the animals that suffer unimaginable deaths every single day on their way to our sandwiches, tacos, etc:
Pigs are very clean animals who take to the mud primarily to cool off and evade flies. They are just as friendly and gregarious as dogs, and according to Professor Donald Broom at the Cambridge University Veterinary School, “They have the cognitive ability to be quite sophisticated. Even more so than dogs and certainly three-year-olds.” Mother pigs in factory farms in the U.S. live most of their lives in individual crates that are 7 feet long and 2 feet wide. They display signs of extreme boredom and stress, such as biting the bars of their cages and gnashing their teeth. Their piglets are taken away three weeks after birth and packed into pens until they are singled out to be raised for breeding or for meat. Like chickens and turkeys, pigs are genetically manipulated and pumped full of drugs, and many become crippled under their own weight. Although pigs are naturally affable and social animals, the confinement of these crowded pens causes neurotic behaviors such as cannibalism and tail-biting, so farmers use pliers to break off the ends of piglets’ teeth and cut off their tails without any painkillers.
Makes being thrown off a cliff sound pretty humane.
Tags: 9-11 | cats | dogs | euthanized | factory farms | fake | humane | marine | meme | off cliff | pigs | puppy | puppygate | thrown | viral
10 Responses for "Hypocrisy, Meme Wars, and the Great Puppy Conspiracy"
boy, your argument is completely whack. you fail to draw logical conclusions and use the premise of one argument to justify your conclusion in the other. FAIL.
Fail comment is fail.
You wrote: “Who are we to decry the senseless death of one animal, when everyday in every single city in our entire country, who legions of animals are routinely slaughtered, for food, because they’re “pests”, or because they happen to walk onto our roads?” How ridiculous. Your argument makes no real sense. Try again.
Yeah you guys are right. Let’s get the bastard, that guy who might have killed one puppy! Lets bring him to justice!!!11 Puppies FTW!
I think the comparison between the birdshit video and the dog video is pretty sorry.
Yes, theres a possibility that the video may be fake but it surely didn’t appear to be. The only thing that would make me elude to the fact that it is - is the poor quality of the video in general. Because of that, no absolute claims can be made i suppose. But the birdshit video was totally different. That was like watching naked gun. Poor comparison.
The video looked real enough to me though. Seems like you just dont want to accept the possibility that it is, or that someone would willingly do something like that?
Im not justifying the people writing letter to the dudes mom and what have you cuz thats on them, but people definitely have a right to think this guys is a total piece a shit. I dont see any evidence to prove otherwise.
You idiots all seem to be missing the fucking point - he has openly admitted, in a message on his myspace profile and in a comment to one of his friends that he fucking DID IT.
In it he mentions along the lines of: ‘We cant take them home, we usually shoot them,for some reason i felt different that day blah blah blah’.
HIS WORDS. NO DENIAL. HE ADMITS HE DID IT. FUCKING GOOGLE IT!
He messages his friend ‘chasity’ - who has put up a poster on her myspace page as part of her own hate campaign, saying: 2 bullets, 2 bodybags, priceless.
It’s not a fucking fake and never will be, either that or he’s part of the conspiracy too. Jesus get a fucking life!
I know it’s hard to accept but this asshole actually went and did this. THAT is why so many people are outraged and why talking about it being a fake is as retarded as you can get.
http://www.albertastars.com/userphotos/1233_3238_R.JPG
Straight from David motari’s keyboard to his friend.
It ISNT fake, would everyone stop trying to make out it is - dont give the guy that priveledge to claim some kind of innocence.
So this jackass is trying to say that people slaughtering animals in a humane way for food is the same thing as tossing a 2 month old puppy over a cliff for nothing but sadistic pleasure??? Whoever wrote this is just as sick and ignorant as that disgrace of a soldier. Go to hell
what a fucking idiot this guy is. i agree with vipes.
YOU MAKE NO SENSE YOU TWAT. IT OBVIOUSLY SHOWS HOW YOU DON’T CARE AT ALL ABOUT INNOCENT, DEFENSLESS ANIMALS AS MUCH AS THE MARINE DOES, AND YOU ARE DEFENDING HIM FOR WHAT GODDAMN REASON!!!
Daniel, you logic truly doesn’t make sense. I would be happy to share more information about the politics and struggles humane educators face every day. Somehow I don’t think you would be open to such information. I’m not sure why people think because violence exists one place, that it makes it OK or even understandable for it to exist in another place. One brutal action will never justify another. You spent the time and energy to write a piece that clearly has an audience. Why not write something that would actually help the situation. Not perpetuate it. In my opinion this has just made you part of the problem, not the solution.
Leave a reply